Which Tool Is Best for Modern SRM?


Procurement teams across the globe are under pressure to deliver supplier accountability, sustainability, and risk transparency — without adding headcount. As a result, supplier scorecard software is moving from a “nice to have” to a strategic necessity.

But which tool is best?

In this guide, we compare EvaluationsHub, SAP Ariba, Jaggaer, Synertrade, Coupa, MeRLIN, Zycus, and other key players. We evaluate how each performs across what really matters in 2025: integration, automation, usability, actionability, and collaboration.

Let’s find the best match for your business.


📊 At a Glance: Top Supplier Scorecard Software Tools in 2025

Tool Best For ERP Integration Supplier Collaboration Templates & Automation Strengths Weaknesses
EvaluationsHub Mid-large companies using ERP, wanting accountability layer ✅ Native on-top integration (SAP, Oracle, Excel) ✅ Full two-way ✅ Yes, with workflow builder Lightweight layer, “close-the-loop”, action-tracking Newer brand, fewer built-in sourcing tools
SAP Ariba Scorecarding SAP-heavy enterprises ✅ Deep SAP integration ❌ Mostly internal view ⚠️ Limited automation Native SAP compatibility Complex, expensive, poor supplier UI
Jaggaer Universities, large supply chains ✅ Jaggaer One ecosystem ⚠️ Partial ✅ Extensive forms Strong in education/Gov UX is dated, admin-heavy
Coupa Enterprises with spend focus ✅ Coupa-native ⚠️ Moderate ✅ Good analytics Strong for finance/procurement ops Scorecarding not central
Zycus iPerform Indian/global MNCs ✅ via Zycus iSource/iSupplier ❌ Internal only ⚠️ Semi-automated Suite cohesion Slower rollouts, rigid
Synertrade European mid-market ✅ SAP/Oracle APIs ❌ Internal-focused ⚠️ Manual workflows Flexible pricing UX/UI not intuitive
MeRLIN Emerging markets & value-focused orgs ✅ Moderate ⚠️ Light portals ⚠️ Templates available Modular and low-cost Limited brand trust, not plug-and-play

🏆 Why EvaluationsHub Stands Out

EvaluationsHub is designed specifically for companies that:

  • Already have an ERP system (SAP, Oracle, Dynamics, etc.)

  • Need a scorecarding and evaluation layer — without replacing existing systems

  • Want to close the loop with suppliers, not just “score” them

  • Care about automation, external collaboration, and template-driven deployment

It delivers what many of the legacy SRM tools don’t:

Feature EvaluationsHub Others
Designed as a lightweight SRM layer ❌ (mostly full-suite, heavy)
Pushes full evaluations to suppliers ❌ (internal-only or form-based)
Built-in follow-ups & action plans ⚠️ (manual tasking)
Real-time dashboards + feedback loop ⚠️
Fast deployment (days, not months)
Supplier-friendly portal ⚠️ (Ariba, Zycus = poor UX)

🔍 Deep-Dive Comparison

1. ERP Integration

Tool Comment
EvaluationsHub Integrates on top of SAP, Oracle, Excel, etc. — no data duplication
SAP Ariba Native SAP, but requires full Ariba suite setup
Coupa Requires Coupa Spend suite — not agnostic
Jaggaer Works best inside its ecosystem
Synertrade, MeRLIN Uses APIs, some setup complexity
Zycus Built into their own platform; not open-layer friendly

➡️ Winner: EvaluationsHub — best for augmenting, not replacing, your ERP.


2. Supplier Collaboration Features

Tool Can suppliers log in? Can they respond or take actions?
EvaluationsHub ✅ Yes ✅ Yes — feedback, uploads, improvements
SAP Ariba ⚠️ Complicated supplier UI ⚠️ Limited two-way interaction
Jaggaer ⚠️ Possible with config ❌ Typically internal-focused
Coupa ⚠️ Some modules ⚠️ Not purpose-built for scorecarding
Zycus, Synertrade ⚠️ Very limited ❌ Often PDF-based or Excel uploads

➡️ Winner: EvaluationsHub — purpose-built for transparent supplier collaboration.


3. Close-the-Loop Functionality

Most tools show performance, but don’t help suppliers act on it. Here’s who closes the loop:

Tool Scorecard → Action Plan → Monitoring
EvaluationsHub ✅ Yes – native action flows + task assignment
SAP Ariba ⚠️ Possible via workflows, not default
Coupa ⚠️ Good analytics but not built-in action tracking
Jaggaer ❌ Manual follow-up
Zycus ⚠️ Form-based
Synertrade, MeRLIN ❌ No built-in feedback/action loop

➡️ Winner: EvaluationsHub — one of the only tools with embedded improvement workflows.


4. Template Library & Workflow Automation

Tool Pre-built scorecards? Automation of surveys / reminders?
EvaluationsHub ✅ Yes — ESG, delivery, risk, etc. ✅ Fully automated with branching
Ariba ⚠️ Basic templates, not dynamic ⚠️ Manual scheduling
Jaggaer ✅ Extensive but complex ⚠️ Partial automation
Coupa ⚠️ Spend-focused templates ⚠️ Requires setup
Zycus, MeRLIN ⚠️ Static ❌ Limited

➡️ Winner: EvaluationsHub — designed for fast starts and repeated use at scale.


5. Ease of Use and Setup Speed

Tool Time to Go Live User-Friendliness
EvaluationsHub Days ✅ Clean UI for buyers + suppliers
SAP Ariba Months ❌ Often requires consultants
Coupa Weeks–Months ⚠️ Better for power users
Jaggaer Weeks ⚠️ Admin-heavy
Zycus, Synertrade Months ⚠️ Clunky interfaces

➡️ Winner: EvaluationsHub — the fastest time-to-value with the lowest friction.


🛠️ Which Tool Should You Choose?

Use Case Recommended Tool
You already use SAP, but don’t want to buy Ariba EvaluationsHub
You want real collaboration with suppliers EvaluationsHub
You need fast deployment and action tracking EvaluationsHub
You’re already deep in the Coupa ecosystem Coupa
You need scorecarding plus full sourcing suite Jaggaer, Zycus
You want low-cost solution in emerging markets MeRLIN

Real-World Insight

Most tools in this space were built as part of full SRM suites. They’re heavy, slow to deploy, and focused on internal processes. EvaluationsHub flips that model.

It’s the only tool in this comparison that:

  • Was designed from day one to be a smart supplier-facing layer

  • Emphasizes accountability and collaboration

  • Supports automated scorecarding at scale

  • Enables corrective actions, not just evaluations

For companies that already have ERP but want better SRM without massive IT projects, the best tool is clear.


TL;DR: EvaluationsHub vs. the Rest

Criteria EvaluationsHub Most Others
Deployment time Days Months
ERP Layered Integration ⚠️ / ❌
Supplier Portal Built-in, seamless Clunky or absent
Close-the-loop actions ✅ Yes ⚠️ / ❌
Template library ✅ With ESG, quality, etc. ⚠️ Partial
AI/automation ✅ Smart flows ❌ Mostly manual
Ideal for Companies with ERP wanting better SRM Companies buying full suites

Final Word

Supplier performance management is no longer about scoring vendors once a year.
It’s about building continuous accountability, transparency, and alignment.

That means:

  • Structured, repeatable evaluations

  • Two-way collaboration

  • Automated follow-up and improvement

  • Deep insights from existing ERP data

That means: EvaluationsHub.

You might also be interested in these blog articles:

Supplier scorecard software

Master Contract Compliance with EvaluationsHub

Introduction to Modern Supply Chain Challenges and the Limits of Traditional Tools

In today’s rapidly evolving market environment, purchasing managers are increasingly facing complex challenges that test the limits of traditional supply chain management tools. As globalization expands and customer expectations rise, the need for more sophisticated, responsive, and adaptable strategies becomes apparent. This section explores some of these modern supply chain challenges and why traditional tools like spreadsheets are becoming obsolete.

Firstly, the sheer volume of data involved in managing contemporary supply chains can be overwhelming. Traditional methods such as spreadsheets are not only time-consuming but also prone to errors when handling large datasets. They lack real-time updating capabilities which are crucial in a dynamic environment where conditions change swiftly.

Secondly, collaboration across various departments and with external suppliers can be cumbersome using spreadsheets. In today’s interconnected world, purchasing managers need tools that facilitate seamless communication and information sharing to enhance decision-making processes efficiently.

Moreover, risk management has become more complicated due to factors such as geopolitical tensions, economic fluctuations, and environmental concerns. Spreadsheets offer limited functionality in terms of analytics and forecasting which is essential for anticipating market changes and mitigating potential risks effectively.

Last but not least, compliance requirements have tightened globally making it imperative for businesses to maintain detailed records that comply with industry standards and regulations—a task poorly suited for basic spreadsheet applications.

In conclusion,EvaluationsHub, as a dedicated supplier relationship management (SRM) platform designed specifically for modern needs offers distinct advantages over traditional tools by addressing these critical issues directly through enhanced features built into its core functionality.

Comprehensive Overview of EvaluationsHub: Features That Enhance Purchasing Management

In the intricate world of supply chain management, EvaluationsHub emerges as a transformative tool designed to streamline and enhance purchasing processes. This platform offers a suite of features tailored specifically for the needs of purchasing managers who are looking to move beyond the limitations of traditional spreadsheets.

  • Centralized Supplier Data Management: EvaluationsHub provides a unified repository where all supplier data is integrated and accessible in real-time. This eliminates data silos and ensures that decision-makers always have up-to-date information at their fingertips.
  • Risk Management Tools: With built-in analytics to assess supplier risk based on performance, compliance, and market factors, EvaluationsHub helps purchasing managers mitigate potential disruptions proactively.
  • Performance Tracking: The platform includes comprehensive tracking tools that monitor supplier performance against contracts and SLAs. These tools enable managers to identify areas needing improvement or renegotiation swiftly.
  • Automated Workflow Processes: By automating routine tasks like purchase order generation, invoice reconciliation, and payment processing, EvaluationsHub frees up valuable time for strategic activities rather than administrative overhead.
  • Cross-functional Collaboration: Facilitating better communication across departments, the platform includes features that allow various teams within an organization to collaborate easily on procurement tasks without miscommunication or delays.

The integration capabilities extend even further with APIs that connect seamlessly with other enterprise systems such as ERP or CRM platforms. This holistic approach not only simplifies workflows but also enhances visibility across all stages of the procurement process. By leveraging advanced reporting functionalities within EvaluationsHub, users can generate insightful reports that drive smarter business decisions making this tool an indispensable asset for any forward-thinking purchasing department.

In essence,EvaluationsHub‘s robust feature set transforms supply chain operations by fostering efficiency through innovation—redefining what’s possible in modern-day purchasing management scenarios.

Key Benefits of Switching from Spreadsheets to EvaluationsHub for Supplier Relationship Management

In the rapidly evolving landscape of supply chain management, purchasing managers are increasingly recognizing the limitations of traditional tools like spreadsheets. EvaluationsHub emerges as a dedicated Supplier Relationship Management (SRM) platform that offers distinct advantages over these outdated methods. Here are some key benefits of making the switch to EvaluationsHub:

  • Enhanced Data Integrity and Security: Unlike spreadsheets that can be prone to errors and data breaches, EvaluationsHub provides a secure environment with controlled access features. This ensures data integrity and reduces risks associated with manual entry and manipulation.
  • Real-Time Analytics and Reporting: With EvaluationsHub, purchasing managers gain access to real-time analytics that allow for immediate insights into supplier performance and market dynamics. This facilitates more informed decision-making compared to the static nature of spreadsheet-based reports.
  • Improved Collaboration Across Teams: The platform fosters better collaboration among team members by providing a centralized repository for all supplier-related information. This eliminates silos within departments, ensuring everyone is on the same page without having multiple versions of documents floating around.
  • Scaled Supplier Engagement: As businesses grow, managing an increasing number of suppliers through spreadsheets becomes cumbersome and inefficient. EvaluationsHub scales effortlessly with your business needs, simplifying processes such as vendor onboarding, performance tracking, and compliance checks through automated workflows.
  • Focused Strategic Insights: Instead of getting bogged down in operational details handled by spreadsheets, purchasing managers can leverage EvaluationsHub’s strategic tools designed for high-level analysis and future planning. This shifts focus from mundane tasks to strategic growth opportunities in supplier relationships.

Making the transition from spreadsheets to a sophisticated tool like EvaluationsHub not only streamlines operations but also significantly enhances strategic decision-making capabilities in supplier relationship management—turning challenges into opportunities for growth in today’s competitive markets.

Real-World Success Stories: How Companies Thrive with EvaluationsHub

In the competitive landscape of modern business, purchasing managers often face the challenge of maintaining efficient and effective supplier relationships. As companies search for tools that can streamline their processes, EvaluationsHub has emerged as a powerful solution. Here, we explore several real-world success stories that highlight how different organizations have significantly benefitted from adopting EvaluationsHub over traditional spreadsheet management.

Case Study 1: Global Manufacturing Firm

A leading global manufacturer switched to EvaluationsHub after struggling with the limitations of spreadsheets for handling its complex supplier networks. The transition resulted in a 40% reduction in time spent on vendor evaluations and a notable improvement in procurement decision-making speed and accuracy. The platform’s ability to provide comprehensive analytics helped them identify cost-saving opportunities which led to a 15% reduction in procurement costs within the first year.

Case Study 2: Retail Chain Group

A prominent retail chain found it challenging to manage its vast array of suppliers across multiple regions using conventional tools. After integrating EvaluationsHub into their system, they experienced enhanced visibility into supplier performance and compliance through real-time dashboards and reports. This capability enabled more strategic vendor partnerships and improved product quality across stores, enhancing customer satisfaction levels significantly.

Case Study 3: Health Care Provider Network

Facing stringent regulatory requirements, a healthcare provider network adopted EvaluationsHub to better manage its suppliers crucial for patient care equipment. The platform’s robust compliance tracking features ensured they remained on top of industry standards without cumbersome manual checks previously done via spreadsheets. Post-adoption saw an impressive decrease in compliance-related issues by 25%, improving overall operational efficiency.

The shift from traditional spreadsheet-based management systems like MS Excel or Google Sheets to a dedicated Supplier Relationship Management (SRM) platform such as EvaluationsHub not only streamlines operations but also provides strategic insights that propel businesses forward effectively and efficiently.

Steps to Seamlessly Transition from Spreadsheets to EvaluationsHub

Moving from traditional spreadsheet-based management to a sophisticated platform like EvaluationsHub can seem daunting. However, with the right approach, the transition can be smooth and significantly beneficial for your organization. Here are actionable steps to ensure a seamless shift:

  1. Assess Current Processes: Begin by thoroughly assessing your existing supplier management processes. Identify what is currently managed through spreadsheets – from supplier scores, contract terms, compliance tracking to performance metrics.
  2. Data Auditing: Evaluate the data you have in your spreadsheets for accuracy and completeness. Cleanse any outdated or incorrect information before migration so that EvaluationsHub starts with the most accurate and up-to-date data.
  3. Choose Your Implementation Team: Assemble a team that includes key stakeholders in supply chain operations along with IT support staff who understand both the technical and functional aspects of EvaluationsHub.
  4. Training and Onboarding: Invest in comprehensive training sessions provided by EvaluationsHub experts. Ensuring everyone understands how to use the new system effectively is crucial for adoption and success.
  5. Pilot Testing Phase: Run a pilot testing phase where you use EvaluationsHub alongside your current spreadsheet method. This dual running helps identify discrepancies or gaps between both systems’ outputs, allowing adjustments before full-scale implementation.
  6. Create Documentation: Create detailed documentation on process changes, user manuals, and best practices as you adapt to the new system. This will serve as valuable resources for current adaptation as well as future onboarding efforts within purchasing departments across all levels of expertise.

The move from spreadsheets to an integrated platform like EvaluationsHub not only streamlines processes but also provides enhanced analytical capabilities that leverage real-time data insights into making strategic supplier relationships decisions more efficiently.
With careful planning using these steps above ensures minimal disruption during this transition while positioning your procurement department at the forefront of modern supply chain management techniques.